PayPal: Payments and Profitability

PayPal is one of the most widely used digital payments platforms in the world, connecting consumers and merchants across online and in-store commerce. From its familiar checkout button to services like Venmo, buy now pay later, and merchant processing, the company sits at the center of everyday transactions and global e-commerce. As payments shift toward mobile wallets, instant transfers, and AI-driven shopping, PayPal is evolving from a fast-growing disruptor into a mature financial platform focused on engagement, efficiency, and new use cases. The question remains: Does this payments network still offer long-term investment potential?

This is not a financial advice. I am not a financial advisor and I only do these post in order to do my own analysis and elaborate about my decisions, especially for my copiers and followers. If you consider investing in any of the ideas I present, you should do your own research or contact a professional financial advisor, as all investing comes with a risk of losing money. You are also more than welcome to copy me. 

For full disclosure, I should mention that I do not own any shares in PayPal at the time of writing this analysis. If you would like to copy or view my portfolio, you can find instructions on how to do so here. If you want to purchase shares or fractional shares of PayPal, you can do so through eToro. eToro is a highly user-friendly platform that allows you to get started on investing with as little as $50.

The Business

PayPal Holdings operates a global digital payments platform that connects consumers and merchants in more than 200 countries. The company functions as an intermediary layer of trust and infrastructure, allowing users to send, receive, and store money digitally while enabling merchants to accept payments both online and in person. At its core, PayPal runs a large two sided network consisting of roughly 439 million active accounts and more than 36 million merchant relationships. This ecosystem processes trillions of dollars in annual payment volume across consumer to merchant purchases, peer to peer transfers, and business payouts. Consumers use PayPal’s digital wallets to shop online or in stores, transfer money to friends and family, hold balances, manage finances, and access services such as buy now pay later and cryptocurrency transactions. The wallet can be funded through bank accounts, cards, balances, or other stored value options, allowing flexible payment choices across devices and operating systems. Merchants use PayPal to accept branded checkout payments, process unbranded payments, manage fraud risk, access working capital financing, send payouts, and improve conversion rates. The company provides omnichannel tools for both small businesses and large enterprises. Most revenue comes from transaction fees charged on the volume of payments processed, often referred to as the take rate. Additional income comes from currency conversion, instant withdrawals, and payment related services. Another part of revenue comes from value added services such as consumer and merchant lending, referral and subscription fees, interest earned on customer balances, and financial products including buy now pay later and cryptocurrency functionality. Over time PayPal has evolved from a fast growing disruptor into a mature financial infrastructure platform generating significant cash flow. PayPal's competitive moat comes from network effects, scale, switching costs, and trust reinforcing each other. The company’s position is primarily driven by its two sided network. A large merchant base attracts consumers because PayPal is widely accepted, while widespread consumer adoption incentivizes merchants to continue offering it. This reinforcing cycle creates switching friction because removing PayPal risks lost conversions for merchants and reduced usability for customers. The scale of hundreds of millions of accounts across global markets makes replication difficult for new entrants. Trust also plays a central role. PayPal has built a long standing reputation for security and buyer protection, which encourages repeat usage. Payments involve sensitive financial information and users often prefer a familiar intermediary, making behavior slow to change even when alternatives exist. PayPal works across devices, operating systems, and payment methods rather than being tied to a specific phone or software ecosystem. Unlike wallets built directly into certain operating systems, it can be used regardless of the user’s device or marketplace. This broad compatibility makes it easier for both consumers and merchants to rely on PayPal as a consistent payment option. The large volume of transactions generates extensive data that improves fraud detection, risk management, and credit underwriting. Combined with global regulatory licenses and compliance infrastructure, this scale creates barriers that are operationally and legally difficult to replicate. Finally the company benefits from diversified monetization. Revenue streams extend beyond checkout fees into instant transfers, foreign exchange, lending products, buy now pay later, interest on balances, and other services. This diversification increases resilience as payment pricing pressure rises and strengthens long term economics.

Management

Enrique Lores serves as the CEO of PayPal, a role he assumed in March 2025 after previously serving as CEO of HP Inc.. He brings decades of experience leading large global technology organizations, with a track record centered on operational discipline, simplification of complex businesses, and performance improvement. Enrique Lores originally joined HP in 1989 as an engineering intern and spent more than thirty years advancing through leadership roles across engineering, strategy, operations, and business management. He holds a bachelor’s degree in electrical engineering from the Polytechnic University of Valencia and an MBA from Esade Business School. Prior to becoming CEO of PayPal, he also served on the company’s board of directors, giving him familiarity with digital platforms and global consumer technology trends before taking on the executive role. During his tenure at HP, Enrique Lores played a central role in the 2015 separation of Hewlett Packard, one of the most complex corporate breakups in modern business history. Following the split, he helped reshape the company’s operating model by simplifying the organization, enforcing cost discipline, and reallocating resources toward higher return initiatives. These efforts improved profitability, strengthened cash generation, and increased strategic focus. As CEO of HP, Enrique Lores focused on keeping the business relevant in a changing technology landscape by expanding into higher growth categories such as gaming, peripherals, services, and AI enabled computing while protecting the company’s large printing cash flows. He also emphasized subscription and recurring revenue models and oversaw investments in hybrid work solutions, security, and digital services. He demonstrated decisiveness in defending the company against a hostile takeover attempt by Xerox Holdings supported by activist investor Carl Icahn, reinforcing long term strategic independence. At PayPal, Enrique Lores is expected to apply a similar playbook. Management has highlighted his experience driving disciplined execution, simplifying complex organizations, and accelerating performance improvement initiatives. He has already been involved in shaping capital allocation priorities, investment decisions, and forward guidance, with a focus on strengthening operational focus and building continuity on existing initiatives. Overall, Enrique Lores is viewed as a transformation oriented operator rather than a product visionary, with strengths in execution, cost discipline, and organizational alignment. His history of restructuring large technology businesses and improving efficiency suggests he was chosen to stabilize performance and sharpen strategic focus as PayPal transitions from a high growth disruptor to a more mature financial infrastructure platform.

The Numbers

The first number we will investigate is the return on invested capital, also known as ROIC. We want to review a 10-year history, with all figures exceeding 10% for each year.  The numbers show that PayPal’s returns were very stable for many years, mostly fluctuating around 9 to 11% between 2016 and 2022. That kind of stability is typical for a payments network that is still expanding, because the company was prioritizing growth, adding users, building Venmo, expanding internationally, and launching new services rather than optimizing profitability. In other words, the economics were intentionally diluted by reinvestment. Starting in 2023 the returns begin to rise meaningfully, reaching almost 15% in 2025. This shift is not random but reflects a structural change in the business. After growth slowed in 2022 the company reduced expenses and focused more on efficiency, which quickly improves returns because the platform already operates with large fixed infrastructure. At the same time a larger share of volume moved toward processing activity that requires very little additional capital, so even without large margin expansion the capital efficiency improved. As the network matured, each additional transaction required almost no new investment since the global infrastructure, licenses, and compliance systems were already built. Mature payment networks therefore naturally experience rising returns even if revenue growth moderates. The improvement therefore looks less like a temporary peak and more like a change in the company’s stage of development. PayPal appears to be moving from a growth focused company into a mature cash generating platform where scale and operating leverage play a larger role. Returns are unlikely to keep rising at the same pace because pricing pressure and competition limit margin expansion and the company will still invest in parts of the business, but it now likely operates from a higher level than before. Instead of staying around roughly 10% as it did for many years, returns may settle in the mid teens and slowly improve over time as additional payment volume requires very little additional capital.

The next numbers are the book value + dividend. In my old format this was known as the equity growth rate. It was the most important of the four growth rates I used to use in my analyses, which is why I will continue to use it moving forward. As you are used to see the numbers in percentage, I have decided to share both the numbers and the percentage growth year over year. To put it simply, equity is the part of the company that belongs to its shareholders – like the portion of a house you truly own after paying off part of the mortgage. Growing equity over time means the company is becoming more valuable for its owners. So, when we track book value plus dividends, we’re essentially looking at how much value is being built for shareholders year after year. Over the past decade PayPal’s equity has not followed a steady upward path and during the last six years it has remained roughly around the same level with only small increases and decreases from year to year. This does not mean the company stopped generating profits. Instead it reflects how the company uses its cash. PayPal has increasingly returned money to shareholders through share repurchases rather than keeping it on the balance sheet. When a company buys back shares, cash leaves the business and equity declines, even though each remaining share represents a larger ownership stake. Because of this, equity growth appears weak even while earnings and cash flow remain healthy. For a mature payments platform this is normal behavior. The business no longer needs large amounts of capital to operate, so excess cash is distributed rather than accumulated. The stable equity level therefore signals a focus on improving value per share rather than expanding the balance sheet. Looking ahead, equity is unlikely to grow quickly unless PayPal changes its strategy, keeps more earnings, or makes large acquisitions. As long as buybacks remain a central part of capital allocation, equity will probably stay relatively stable, while value creation instead shows up in higher earnings per share and free cash flow per share.

Finally, we will analyze the free cash flow. Free cash flow, in short, refers to the cash that a company generates after covering its operating expenses and capital expenditures. I use levered free cash flow margin because I believe that the margin provides a better understanding of the numbers. Free cash flow yield refers to the amount of free cash flow per share that a company is expected to generate in relation to its market value per share. Since around 2020 PayPal’s free cash flow has mostly stayed within a similar range even though payment volume kept growing. The jump in 2024 therefore looks more like an especially efficient year than a permanent step up. The main reason cash flow has not grown faster is that the company has been investing heavily in new initiatives such as improving Venmo monetization, expanding buy now pay later and credit products, building omnichannel payments, and upgrading its technology. These types of investments run through everyday operating expenses rather than big one-time projects, so they directly reduce the cash left over each year even while the business itself becomes stronger. At the same time a larger share of payments now comes from lower priced processing services, which also limits how quickly profits turn into cash. Because of this, free cash flow margins move around from year to year. When PayPal slows hiring, cuts costs, or improves efficiency, cash flow rises quickly as seen in 2024. When the company spends more to grow or launch new products, margins fall again. The payments platform itself is very scalable, so relatively small changes in spending can have a noticeable impact on cash generation in any single year. Going forward management expects free cash flow to increase gradually and roughly follow profit growth rather than jump sharply each year. This suggests a more mature phase where steady improvements and discipline matter more than rapid expansion. Margins will likely still vary from year to year but slowly improve over time as execution and cost control become a larger focus. PayPal mainly uses its free cash flow to return money to shareholders and to invest in the business. The company has been buying back large amounts of shares, around 6 billion dollars annually, and has also started paying a dividend. At the same time it continues investing in product development, artificial intelligence tools, credit services, and expanding payment acceptance both online and in physical stores. This shows a balance between supporting future growth and distributing excess cash once the core platform no longer needs heavy investment. The free cash flow yield suggests the shares may be attractively valued, but valuation will be discussed in more detail later in the analysis.

Debt

Another important aspect to consider is the level of debt and whether it is manageable. We evaluate this by comparing total long-term debt with earnings to estimate how many years of earnings would be needed to repay it. For PayPal this equals 1,97 years, which is comfortably below the three-year threshold and suggests debt is not a concern from an investment perspective. Debt increased slightly in 2025 despite higher earnings mainly because the company has been returning large amounts of cash to shareholders while still keeping some debt on the balance sheet instead of paying it all off. PayPal generates strong cash flow and also holds more cash and investments than total debt, which indicates a comfortable financial position. Since its IPO PayPal has almost always kept its debt at a level that could be repaid within three years of earnings, showing a cautious approach to borrowing. Because the company produces strong cash flow and maintains financial flexibility, debt is unlikely to become a problem in the future.

Unlock Exclusive Seeking Alpha Discounts – Level Up Your Investing With Zero Risk

If you’ve been thinking about improving your investing process, this is the easiest way to start. These offers are only available through my links, and the Premium plan even comes with a 100% risk-free 7-day trial. Try everything for a week, and if it’s not for you, just cancel. You lose nothing.

1) Seeking Alpha Premium — Try It Free for 7 Days

Access the tools I personally use every day:

• Earnings transcripts

• Stock screeners

• Deep-dive analysis

• Portfolio tracking

• Market news with context that actually matters

Special Price: $269/year (normally $299) + 7-day free trial (for new users only)

Try Premium Free for 7 Days → HERE

(Explore everything — cancel anytime during the trial and pay $0.)

2) Alpha Picks — Proven Stock Ideas

This stock-picking service has delivered +287% returns vs. the S&P 500’s +77% (July 2022–Nov 2025).Great for investors who want curated, long-term picks backed by data.

Special Price: $449/year (normally $499)

Get Alpha Picks → HERE

(Although Alpha Picks doesn’t offer a free trial, its historical outperformance means the subscription can often pay for itself quickly if results persist. For many investors, the potential return far outweighs the upfront cost).

3) Premium + Alpha Picks Bundle — Best Value

Get both services together and save $159.Perfect if you want both broad tools and high-conviction stock ideas.

Special Price: $639/year (normally $798)

Get the Bundle → HERE

(This bundle doesn’t include a free trial, but it gives you both services at a $159 discount. You get Premium’s in-depth research plus Alpha Picks’ high-performing recommendations, making it the most comprehensive option for serious investors.)

Risks

Competition is a risk for PayPal because the global payments industry is highly competitive, dynamic, and constantly evolving. PayPal competes with traditional banks, card networks, technology companies, payment processors, and newer fintech firms, all of which have different advantages that can gradually pressure its market share, pricing power, and profitability. One of the most important changes is how payments have moved to the smartphone. Mobile wallets such as Apple Pay and Google Pay are built directly into the operating system of the phone and allow users to pay instantly with a fingerprint or face scan. Because they remove friction from the checkout process, consumers often default to them when available. This weakens PayPal’s position, especially in physical stores and mobile shopping, since users must actively choose PayPal rather than automatically using the wallet already built into their device. In addition, Apple Pay does not allow payments directly from a PayPal balance, meaning PayPal can lose the customer relationship even if the user still has a PayPal account. At the same time the underlying payment infrastructure is becoming simpler and faster. Real time bank transfer systems allow money to move instantly between accounts without needing an intermediary to simplify the transaction. As transfers become easier and nearly invisible to the user, the value of an extra payment layer decreases, which can reduce PayPal’s relevance in certain use cases. Merchant services face strong competition as well. Companies like Stripe, Adyen, and Block offer modern payment infrastructure that integrates directly into websites and apps and often bundle additional tools such as analytics, fraud prevention, and embedded financial services. Large merchants frequently compare providers based on cost and performance, and if PayPal must lower prices to remain competitive its margins could decline. This is particularly relevant in its unbranded processing business where pricing competition is intense. Peer to peer payments are also under pressure. In the United States, services like Zelle are integrated directly into bank apps, allowing users to send money instantly without creating a separate account. Because these transfers happen inside existing banking relationships, they can reduce the need for standalone apps such as Venmo in certain situations. Finally, traditional financial institutions and card networks continue to expand their own digital capabilities. Banks, Visa, and Mastercard increasingly offer direct transfers, stored credentials, and contactless payments, making many of PayPal’s original advantages more widely available across the financial system.

Regulatory scrutiny is a risk for PayPal because it operates as a financial intermediary in many countries, which means it is treated less like a technology company and more like a bank-like institution. As digital payments grow in importance, governments increasingly want tighter oversight of how money moves, how customer data is handled, and how consumers are protected. This creates ongoing uncertainty and rising compliance costs. PayPal must follow a large number of rules covering anti-money laundering, fraud prevention, sanctions, lending, consumer protection, privacy, and cybersecurity. These rules differ across countries and change frequently. Each time regulators update requirements, PayPal may need to modify its systems, verify more customer information, or add additional controls. That can slow onboarding, add friction to payments, and increase operating expenses. In extreme cases failure to comply can lead to fines, restrictions, or the loss of licenses needed to operate in certain markets. Consumer protection oversight is also intensifying. Authorities such as the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau monitor areas like payment errors, account freezes, and dispute resolution. Because PayPal directly handles customer balances, complaints about account closures or fund holds can lead to investigations or lawsuits. Even if the company ultimately complies with the rules, defending and adapting to these cases consumes management attention and resources. Data privacy is another major area of risk. PayPal processes large amounts of financial and personal information across borders, and many countries are introducing stricter privacy laws. New regulations may limit how data can be used for fraud detection, personalization, or marketing. If the company must change how it processes data, some services could become less effective or more expensive to operate. Regulation also affects pricing and product design. Authorities in several regions already cap certain payment fees, and future rules such as open banking could allow direct bank-to-bank payments without intermediaries. If regulators push for cheaper payment access or force broader network access, PayPal’s ability to charge fees could be reduced. Similarly, lending and buy now pay later products are increasingly being brought under traditional credit laws, which may restrict growth or require more underwriting. Finally, because PayPal operates globally, a single issue can trigger overlapping investigations across multiple jurisdictions. Even when problems are minor, they can lead to reputational damage, negative publicity, or required operational changes. Over time the combination of compliance costs, legal risk, and limits on pricing flexibility can weigh on profitability and growth if regulation continues to tighten.

Macroeconomics is a risk for PayPal because the company earns money when people and businesses transact. If economic activity slows, transaction volumes fall and revenue follows. Consumer spending is especially important, and during periods of high living costs and high interest rates households typically reduce discretionary purchases such as retail and travel, areas where PayPal has meaningful exposure. A weaker job market can further reduce confidence and spending, which directly lowers payment volume on the platform. Businesses are affected as well. When merchants sell less, they process fewer payments through PayPal, and they often become more focused on costs. This can lead to tougher pricing negotiations and pressure on fees at the same time as transaction growth slows. Smaller businesses tend to react quickly to economic weakness, which can amplify the effect on PayPal’s network activity. Inflation creates an additional challenge. Higher prices reduce purchasing power and can lead to smaller or fewer purchases even if consumers continue buying essentials. At the same time PayPal’s own operating costs rise, particularly in customer support, technology, and compliance, making it harder to improve profitability when growth is already weaker. Interest rates also influence the business. Higher rates increase borrowing costs for consumers and merchants, which can reduce spending and increase risk in financing products such as buy now pay later and merchant loans. Lower rates have the opposite effect but reduce the income PayPal earns on customer balances, which is part of its value added revenue. Because PayPal operates globally, economic softness in specific regions can slow overall growth even if other markets perform well. Trade tensions, financial market volatility, and changes in fiscal or monetary policy can also reduce confidence and transaction activity. As a result, the company’s growth, margins, and cash generation can vary depending on the strength of the economic environment, making macroeconomic conditions an ongoing risk.

Reasons to invest

Branded checkout is a reason to invest in PayPal because it is one of the company’s most profitable activities and a central driver of long-term economics. When consumers actively choose PayPal at checkout rather than the payment running invisibly in the background, PayPal captures higher transaction margins and strengthens its relationship with both the buyer and the merchant. The main advantage comes from conversion. PayPal stores payment details, addresses, and funding sources in one place, so the checkout process becomes quick and familiar. When users set PayPal as their default payment method, transactions can be completed without entering passwords or card information, producing extremely high completion rates. Merchants benefit because fewer customers abandon their carts, and PayPal benefits because it becomes the preferred payment option rather than just one of many. This improves PayPal’s share of wallet as customers repeatedly choose it for purchases. Buy now pay later embedded directly into checkout reinforces this behavior. Showing installment options at the point of purchase encourages larger baskets and increases purchase likelihood, which helps merchants generate more sales. As merchants see higher conversion and revenue, they have an incentive to promote PayPal more prominently, which in turn drives more usage. This creates a feedback loop where higher merchant placement leads to more consumer adoption, and more consumer adoption leads to better placement. Placement matters significantly. When PayPal is displayed prominently or earlier in the purchase flow, selection rates more than double compared with weaker placement. Upfront messaging about paying over time and rewards further increases usage. As more large merchants integrate these features, PayPal benefits from stronger transaction growth and a reinforcing brand effect across the broader merchant network. User engagement also increases repeat usage. Customers who interact with the PayPal app or rewards features are much more likely to choose PayPal again during future purchases. Over time this turns checkout into a habitual behavior rather than a one-time decision, making the payment choice sticky and harder for competitors to displace. The company is still in the process of rolling these improvements out across its global base, which means the full benefit is not yet reflected in results. Where the redesigned checkout, strong placement, and incentives are fully implemented, merchants have already seen double digit growth in branded payment volume relative to their markets. Because branded checkout accounts for more than half of PayPal’s profit, even modest improvements in adoption can meaningfully improve margins and growth.

Venmo is a reason to invest in PayPal because it represents one of the company’s clearest growth engines and expands PayPal beyond traditional online checkout into everyday financial activity. What began primarily as a peer to peer payment app has been turning into a commerce and financial services platform where transactions generate revenue rather than just engagement. The scale of the user base is important. Venmo has grown to more than 100 million active accounts with strong engagement, especially among younger consumers. That demographic matters because payment habits formed early often persist for years. As these users age and their purchasing power rises, PayPal gains a long-term customer base that can naturally shift from sending money to friends into paying merchants, using cards, and adopting financial services. Monetization has improved significantly. Revenue has been growing quickly and the mix is shifting away from free peer to peer transfers toward commercial activity. Payments made directly to merchants and transactions through the debit card have been expanding much faster than overall usage. This means Venmo is moving from being mainly an engagement platform to becoming a meaningful contributor to profit. The more users pay with Venmo in everyday purchases, the more revenue PayPal earns per user. Venmo also increases ecosystem stickiness. Features such as rewards programs and tiered incentives encourage users to keep balances, use the debit card, and interact frequently with the app. High engagement increases the likelihood that Venmo becomes the default financial hub for younger users rather than just a tool used occasionally. Over time this can deepen relationships and make switching less likely. Another advantage is merchant adoption. As more businesses accept Venmo, it connects social payments with commerce. Users who already trust the app for sending money can seamlessly use it to shop, which reduces friction compared with introducing a completely new payment method. This gradually expands PayPal’s reach into daily spending categories and strengthens its relevance outside traditional online checkout.

Agentic commerce is a reason to invest in PayPal because it positions the company for the next shift in how people shop online. Instead of consumers searching websites and manually checking out, AI assistants will increasingly discover products, compare options, and complete purchases automatically. If that behavior becomes widespread, the payment provider integrated into those AI workflows could control a meaningful portion of future digital commerce. PayPal is trying to make its network the default payment layer inside these AI interactions. Through its agent ready and store sync capabilities, merchants can make their catalogs visible and purchasable inside conversational platforms, while PayPal handles identity verification, fraud protection, and payment processing. This means the checkout step disappears into the background, but PayPal still processes the transaction. By integrating once, merchants can become accessible across multiple AI shopping interfaces, which reduces friction and makes PayPal a central infrastructure provider rather than just a checkout button. The company also benefits from data scale. Processing transactions across millions of merchants gives PayPal detailed information about purchasing patterns, pricing, and consumer behavior. That data can be used to power personalized suggestions and automated purchasing decisions inside AI systems. As shopping shifts from browsing to recommendation driven buying, this kind of transaction history becomes increasingly valuable because the AI needs trusted signals about what to recommend and how to pay securely. Another advantage is trust and protection. Autonomous purchasing requires users and merchants to feel comfortable allowing software to initiate transactions. PayPal already offers buyer protection, dispute handling, and fraud detection, which helps solve one of the main barriers to AI driven commerce. Instead of each AI platform building a payment trust layer from scratch, they can rely on PayPal’s existing infrastructure. Importantly, the strategy focuses on future relevance rather than immediate revenue. The goal is to embed PayPal wherever purchasing decisions happen so that, as shopping moves from web pages to conversational interfaces, PayPal remains part of the transaction flow. If AI assistants become a common way to buy products, payment providers not integrated into those systems could lose visibility and usage. By partnering early and enabling merchants to connect their catalogs directly to AI channels, PayPal increases the likelihood that it remains a standard payment option in that environment.

Support the Blog

I want to keep the blog free and accessible for everyone. If you enjoy the content and would like to support it, you can buy me a cup of coffee through PayPal. Every little bit helps and is truly appreciated!

Valuation

Now it is time to calculate the share price. I perform three different calculations that I learned at a Phil Town seminar. If you want to make the calculations yourself for this or other stocks, you can do so through the tools page on my website, where you have access to all three calculators for free.

The first is called the Margin of Safety price, which is calculated based on earnings per share (EPS), estimated future EPS growth, and estimated future price-to-earnings ratio (P/E). The minimum acceptable rate of return is 15%. I chose to use an EPS of 5,41, which is from 2025. I have selected a projected future EPS growth rate of 7%. Finbox expects EPS to grow by an average of 7,7% in the next 5 years. Additionally, I have selected a projected future P/E ratio of 14, which is double the growth rate. This decision is based on PayPal's historically higher price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio. Finally, our minimum acceptable rate of return has already been established at 15%. After performing the calculations, we determined the sticker price (also known as fair value or intrinsic value) to be $36,83. We want to have a margin of safety of 50%, so we will divide it by 2. This means that we want to buy PayPal at a price of $18,41 (or lower, obviously) if we use the Margin of Safety price.

The second calculation is known as the Ten Cap price. The rate of return that a company owner (or stockholder) receives on the purchase price of the company essentially represents its return on investment. The minimum annual return should be at least 10%, which I calculate as follows: The operating cash flow last year was 6.416, and capital expenditures were 852. I attempted to analyze their annual report to calculate the percentage of capital expenditures allocated to maintenance. I couldn't find it, but as a rule of thumb, you can expect that 70% of the capital expenditures will be allocated to maintenance purposes. This means that we will use 596 in our calculations. The tax provision was 1.059. We have 935,7 outstanding shares. Hence, the calculation will be as follows: (6.416 – 596 + 1.059) / 935,7 x 10 = $73,52 in Ten Cap price.

The final calculation is referred to as the Payback Time price. It is a calculation based on the free cash flow per share. With PayPal's free cash flow per share at $5,95 and a growth rate of 7%, if you want to recoup your investment in 8 years, the Payback Time price is $65,32.

Conclusion

I believe PayPal is an intriguing company, though there is some uncertainty around the new management. The company has built a competitive moat through network effects, scale, switching costs, and trust reinforcing each other. ROIC have been stable historically and may gradually rise as PayPal transitions from a growth focused company into a more mature cash generating platform. Management expects free cash flow to grow roughly in line with profits rather than in sharp jumps, supporting shareholder returns through buybacks and dividends. Competition remains a risk because many alternatives now offer fast built in payment options, including mobile wallets, instant bank transfers, and modern processors that compete on convenience and price and can shift transactions away from PayPal while pressuring margins. Regulatory scrutiny is also a risk since PayPal operates across many jurisdictions under financial regulations covering payments, data, and consumer protection, which can raise costs, add friction, or limit certain services. Macroeconomic conditions matter as well because weaker spending, inflation, and interest rate changes can reduce transaction volume, pressure fees, and affect financing income. On the positive side, branded checkout supports higher margins and loyalty when consumers actively choose PayPal, and features like buy now pay later improve conversion and repeat usage. Venmo provides an additional growth path as it evolves from peer to peer payments into a broader commerce and financial platform with a large engaged user base. Agentic commerce offers longer term potential by embedding PayPal into AI driven purchasing so transactions can still flow through its network even if traditional checkout changes. While there are clear strengths, I believe the uncertainties around future growth are significant enough that I will not invest in PayPal at this time.

My personal goal with investing is financial freedom. It also means that to obtain that, I do different things to build my wealth. If you have some extra hours to spare each month, you can turn a few hours a week into a substantial amount of money in a few years. If you are interested to know how I do it, you can read this post.

I hope you enjoyed my analysis! While I can’t post about every company I analyze, you can stay updated on my trades by following me on Twitter. I share real-time updates whenever I buy or sell, so if you’re making your own investment decisions, be sure to follow along!

Some of the greatest investors in the world believe in karma, and in order to receive, you will have to give (Warren Buffett and Mohnish Pabrai are great examples). If you appreciated my analysis and want to get some good karma, I would kindly ask you to donate a bit to Rolda Animal Rescue. It is an organization that is helping the animals in Ukraine, and they need all the help they can get. If you have a little to spare, please donate here. Even a little will make a huge difference to save these wonderful animals. Thank you.